Thursday, December 3, 2020

Don’t Pardon Book Industry Scoundrels, Failures, & Losers


“A pardon is a government decision to allow a person to be relieved of some or all of the legal consequences resulting from a criminal conviction. A pardon may be granted before or after conviction for the crime, depending on the laws of the jurisdiction.”  -- Wikipedia

Outgoing President Donald Trump is rumored to be scheming to pardon family members, close associates, friends, and possibly himself for any and all crimes that they have not even been charged with, let alone convicted. Constitutional challenges and moral outrage aside, this topic made me think about potential pardons for the book industry. If I had the power to pardon people as it relates to the book world, who or what would I forgive? 

Sorry, but no one deserves to be absolved of their wrongdoing in the book world. I would not give pardons to any of the following scoundrels and losers: 


They own the book industry. They publish books. They self-publish. They sell new and used books. Everyone is overly dependent on them. What happens when they assert their power and jack up prices, limit what gets sold, put stores out of business, gut jobs, and sell all of their data about readers? 

Simon & Schuster

This publisher of great writers and many bestsellers, sold itself to the highest bidder. Nothing wrong there, except it meant they would join forces with the already biggest publisher, Penguin Random House. Monopolistic companies are not good for any industry. Competition suffers, jobs get cut, book prices go up, and writers have less bargaining power. 

Penguin Random House

They published former President Barack Obama’s best-selling memoir, A Promised Land, and splattered a cover price of $45 on the hardcover. In a sign of greed gone bad, the publisher is ripping off consumers, libraries, and schools. The celebrity memoir is not dead, but the nation’s largest publisher is going to kill the marketplace with such prices during a pandemic-wrecked economy. 

New York Times Book Review

This well-respected institution is the number one book reviewing source, but would it kill them to allow for self-published books, if worthy, to be reviewed? Holding such a baseless prejudice against some award-winning, best-selling books is ridiculous. 

Barnes & Noble

They have been mismanaged for over a decade. Slow to pick up on the e-book craze, they keep playing catch up. They go through a new CEO seemingly every other year and lack vision, leadership, and initiative to make their stores and online business a dominant force.  

Lazy Teachers

I support educators who are driven by passion and a desire to produce better readers and to extinguish illiteracy, However, there are too many bad apples out there. Many take the job because they get summers off and long vacation breaks. They don’t feel invested in raising a smarter generation and too willingly fall victim to a bureaucracy that fails to serve the community. This is no more evident than during corona. Too many teachers fail to show up to school, whether in person or via zoom. As a parent of two school-age children, I am thoroughly disgusted by what I see going on in the public schools. 

Formula-Driven Literary Agents

Literary agents fear becoming irrelevant. Self-publishing and small presses provide options for authors, but they still serve as gatekeepers for the big publishers, and unfortunately they are driven too often by metrics that have little to do with a book’s merit. If you don’t have 20.000 Twitter connections, many will pass over your manuscript. If you don’t indicate you will purchase copies or pay for a publicist, some agents will toss your submission in the garbage. What happened to representing a really good or important book — and not pouring through one’s social media feed first? 

Egotistical Authors

You know who you are. Not every story deserves an audience but you think everyone should drop everything to read your book even when it is dull, poorly edited, and simply not important. You let your ego get in the way of your judgment. Don’t publish garbage and demand we see it as gold.  

The Federal Government

A bailout is needed for the literary arts. Everyone is getting free money but the starving artists. Cough up some dough!  

Literacy Non-Profits

Some do a really good job and some just do a really good job of taking in donations. Literacy should be a basic right, same as food, shelter, clothing, and access to medical care. To be literate means self-sufficiency, positioning one to go from being a taker to a maker, from dependence to independence. So why, after decades and tens of billions in funding, do we still have tens of millions of illiterates in America?   

Okay, so I sound like a moody bitch wearing a Grinch face, but it gets frustrating to see the institutions that we would like or trust to fail us so significantly. This is no time to pardon people in the White House nor in the world of books. It is a time to call these people and institutions out — and to demand a change for the better. If I hurt someone’s feelings, that is good. Shared pain is needed for things to get better.  

 If you think you are part of the problem, cross the line to be a part of the solution.

Learn, Grow, Succeed!!

The Ultimate 2021 Book Marketing Guide

The SECRET Sauce for Book Sales!

Will Books Flourish Under President Joe Biden?

Authors Want Their Drop-The-Mic Moment

Do Writers Know The Power They Wield?

The Rights, Responsibilities, & Resources Available To Writers Today

Do Authors Plan Two Moves Ahead?

Why Good Authors Fail Miserably – And Often

How Authors Should Build A Platform

Brian Feinblum, the founder of BookMarketingBuzzBlog, can be reached at  You can – and should -- follow him on Twitter @theprexpert. This is copyrighted by BookMarketingBuzzBlog ©2020. Born and raised in Brooklyn, he now resides in Westchester with his wife, two kids, and Ferris, a black lab rescue dog. His writings are often featured in The Writer and IBPA’s The Independent.  This was named one of the best book marketing blogs by BookBaby and recognized by Feedspot in 2018 as one of the top book marketing blogs. Also named by as a "best resource.” He recently hosted a panel on book publicity for Book Expo America. For more information, please consult: 


No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.