According to Publishers Weekly, their
best-seller lists continue to be dominated by the top book publishers. 91% of
all best-seller list spots for hardcovers were occupied last year by just five
publishers – up from the 89.1% in 2020. Trade paperbacks showed a similar
dominance by the Big 5 – 77.4% of all such bestseller spots were filled in 2021
by Penguin Random House, Simon & Schuster, Harper Collins, Hachette Book Group,
and Macmillan. The question is: Why?
Traditional publishers, overall, were
responsible for releasing around one out of every six published titles in 2021.
That means they published about 15% of the new books but they took up 91% of
the best-seller space for hardcovers and 77.4% for trade paperbacks.
Let’s explore why – but first, let’s give
credit where credit is due. The Big 5 got to where they are because they
publish quality books from great authors, know how to package them up, utilize
their distribution legs, and call upon their marketing muscle to generate buzz
and sales. Top editors clean up great works that were acquired through a strenuous
elimination process that saw publishers and literary agents filtering out
millions of manuscripts.
Ok, now why are the best-seller lists dominated
by just five publishers?
· These five own many imprints and keep gobbling
up competitors, so it is no wonder that the biggest companies also gobbled up
the biggest sellers.
· Many self-published books are discriminated against
by major book reviewers and bookstores. Without the reviews or shelf space, it
is hard to crack best-seller lists.
· Where books are sold accounts for how these
best-seller lists are tabulated. So, if an author sells lots of books through
their site or at an event -- and are not accounted for by amazon or a book store,
it is as if the sales never happened.
· How sales are calculated impacts these lists.
For instance, a book could sell tens of thousands of copies this year – and not
make a list. Another one can sell 2500 copies and make a list. How is that
possible? The lists tabulate weekly sales at certain book retail outlets. If an
author sells 2500 copies through bookstores in one week, they can hit a list.
If an author sells 1000 a week for 20 weeks, they will never make a list – but outsell
the best-seller overall by 8 to 1.
· Brand name recognition. Readers buy brands they know: big publishing
labels and big-name authors. Bigness begets bigness.
· Dominance of review space and media coverage.
If the media is giving exposure to only certain big-name writers or is more
willing to write about books from certain big-pocket publishers that will then yield
advertisements from that publisher, well, follow the money.
· The marketing budgets of most authors are small
or non-existent; whereas a publisher can put resources into marketing certain
books that will hit a list.
· List manipulation. This occurs every week. Big
marketers know how to buy up copies of the book in a certain manner that allows
a book to hit a list. Some authors will spend well over $200,000 to make a list
– and no one will know that it happened.
The book publishing world of best-seller lists
is not a fully level playing field. Out of two million books published in 2021 –
5,000 a day – it seems only the ones put out by the Big 5 have the ability to
hit a list. We should question why.
Me For Help
Brian Feinblum, the founder of this
award-winning blog, can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org He is available to
help authors promote their story, sell their book, and grow their brand. He has
30 years of experience in successfully helping thousands of authors in all
Happy Holidays! A gift for
A Lifetime Book Marketing Timeline For Authors
What Goals Should
Are Writers America’s Underdog?
Must Authors Be Ready To Speak Again?
Authors Should Expect Changes In 2022
Ask Me Anything About Book Marketing
22 Things Authors Should Do In 2022
Authors: Obey The 10 Golden Rules
Why Readers Can’t Buy
What Authors Won’t Sell
Free 2022 Bestselling Book Marketing & PR E-Book For Writers
Most Popular Author Interviews of the Year! Learn What 32 Writers Say About
Book Publishing – and Their Books.
Publishing Predictions & Trends For 2022
About Brian Feinblum
Brian Feinblum should be followed on Twitter @theprexpert. This
is copyrighted by BookMarketingBuzzBlog ©2022. Born and raised in Brooklyn, he
now resides in Westchester with his wife, two kids, and Ferris, a black lab
rescue dog. His writings are often featured in The Writer and
IBPA’s The Independent. This was named one of the best book
marketing blogs by BookBaby http://blog.bookbaby.com/2013/09/the-best-book-marketing-blogs and recognized by Feedspot in 2018
as one of the top book marketing blogs. It was also named by WinningWriters.com
as a "best resource.” He recently hosted a panel on book publicity
for Book Expo America. For more information, please consult: .